Library
On Writing Well · 2 of 13
On Writing Well
business CRITICAL

Clutter and Compression: The Bracketing Technique

On Writing Well William Zinsser
clutter revision compression bracketing simplicity

Key Principle

Clutter is the primary disease of American prose — and it is not a stylistic flaw but a moral one. Every unnecessary word is a small act of disrespect: it forces the reader to do work the writer should have done. The corrective is the bracketing technique: read a draft and bracket every component that may not be doing useful work, then cut all bracketed material. Most first drafts can be reduced by 50% without losing information or voice.

"Writing improves in direct ratio to the number of things we can keep out of it that shouldn't be there." (Chapter 3: Clutter)

Why This Matters

Clutter accumulates through two mechanisms. The first is social: writers inflate language to sound authoritative or educated, producing prose that serves the writer's anxiety rather than the reader's comprehension. The airline pilot who says "presently anticipating experiencing considerable precipitation" instead of "it may rain" is not confused — he is performing expertise. The second mechanism is viral: a single high-visibility use of a cluttered phrase normalizes it overnight. Writers absorb clutter passively from institutional and political speech, then deploy it without examination.

The reader consequence is mechanical: when a reader loses the thread, they initially blame themselves and re-read. After a few such experiences they stop — and they blame the writer. "The man or woman snoozing in a chair with a magazine is a person who was being given too much unnecessary trouble by the writer." (Chapter 2: Simplicity) Reader patience is finite; the writer who wastes it has failed.

Good Examples

Before/after clutter removal:

  • "It should be noted that the committee has reached consensus on the issue" → "The committee agreed."
  • "At this point in time" → "now"
  • "Presently anticipating experiencing considerable precipitation" → "It may rain."

The Bracketing Technique in practice: Read a draft sentence by sentence. Bracket every word that is not doing necessary work — redundant qualifiers ("very unique"), adjectives restating the noun ("tall skyscraper"), meta-explanatory clusters ("It is interesting to note that"). Then read each sentence without the brackets and decide. The writer cannot defend a word simply because it was written; each word must justify its presence.

The 50 Percent Rule: Most first drafts contain 50% surplus. This is not because writers are careless but because the act of drafting generates excess as a byproduct — repetition, explanation of the self-evident, padding. Removing it forces precision by eliminating the hiding places for imprecision.

Counterpoints

Seven clutter patterns to scan for:

  1. Prepositions appended unnecessarily to verbs ("head up" → "head"; "order up" → "order")
  2. Adjectives restating the noun ("end result," "final outcome," "future plans")
  3. Long words displacing short equivalents ("assistance" → "help"; "utilize" → "use")
  4. Euphemisms replacing uncomfortable truths ("depressed socioeconomic area" → "slum")
  5. Professional pomposity ("Are you experiencing any pain?" → "Does it hurt?")
  6. Meta-explanatory clusters ("It should be noted that..."; "It is interesting to observe that...")
  7. Jargon signaling currency over communication ("at the end of the day," "going forward," "drill down")

The moral dimension: "Orwell's warning that clutter is not just a nuisance but a deadly tool has come true." (Chapter 3: Clutter) Political language deploys clutter deliberately — "reinforced protective reaction strike" for bombing, "involuntary methodologies" for layoffs — to sever the connection between action and accountability. Even in non-political writing, clutter performs the same function: it protects the writer from being held to precise meaning.

Key Quotes

"Clutter is the disease of American writing. We are a society strangling in unnecessary words, circular constructions, pompous frills and meaningless jargon." — William Zinsser, Chapter 2: Simplicity

"But the secret of good writing is to strip every sentence to its cleanest components." — William Zinsser, Chapter 2: Simplicity

"Clear thinking becomes clear writing; one can't exist without the other." — William Zinsser, Chapter 2: Simplicity

"Most first drafts can be cut by 50 percent without losing any information or losing the author's voice." — William Zinsser, Chapter 3: Clutter

Rules of Thumb

  • Bracket every word that isn't doing necessary work. Cut all bracketed material.
  • Ask two questions of every sentence: "What am I trying to say?" and "Have I said it?"
  • Strong verbs make adverbs redundant — if the adverb restates the verb, cut it.
  • Qualifiers ("rather," "quite," "sort of") are confidence failures, not style choices. Delete them.
  • Meta-explanatory phrases ("It should be noted that...") add no content; cut them completely.
  • When stuck, look for the sentence where you first sound like yourself — cut everything before it.

Related References