Library
Experience Design: A Participatory Manifesto · 9 of 12
Experience Design: A Participatory Manifesto
ARG Design HIGH

Implementation Playbook

Experience Design: A Participatory Manifesto Abraham Burickson
implementation phase-zero experiments action-sequence practice

Implementation Playbook

Key Principle: Phase Zero as Starting Protocol

Every experience design project begins before design begins. Phase Zero inverts the conventional sequence: instead of choosing a medium first (film, exhibit, dinner, app) and then filling it with content, the designer determines the desired experience, derives content from that aim, and selects form last and smallest.

The sequence is Experience -> Content -> Form, never Form -> Content. "An experience designer tosses out the traditional form-then-content process in favor of an experience-then-content-then-form process." (p. 14)

The Phase Zero Process

  1. Ask the experiential question. "What experience are we trying to create?" — not "What kind of [medium] will we make?" (p. 14)
  2. Determine experiential aim and scope — physical extent, temporal duration, target immersion depth.
  3. Research which forms, media, and activities could serve that aim. Let the aim generate candidates; do not let your training restrict them.
  4. Identify collaborations required to realize the design. (p. 13)
  5. Plan the immersion arc — how immersion builds, peaks, and releases across time; which touchpoints move the audience along that arc. (p. 75)

Each decision is "not so much a solution to a problem as an opening to experiential possibility." (p. 14)

Why This Matters

Without Phase Zero, form pre-selects every affordance before design thinking starts. A designer who defaults to "play" inherits a 1-3 hour window, a fixed actor-audience relationship, and a set of stage conventions — silently eliminating experiences they never even consider. (p. 12) The client gets a house, not a home: "A house is a spot on a map. A home is an orientation in the world." (p. 13)

Phase Zero also guards against totalitarian design. Total control — no unprogrammed choices, no genuine unknown — eliminates the human quality of experience. "A world with no unprogrammed choices, no true unknown, is not a human world." (p. 14) The protocol must preserve openness, not just optimize for a target state.

Good Examples: The Five Experiments as Progressive Build

The book's embedded Experiments A through E form a cumulative build sequence. Each adds one layer of experience design competence, and the sequence models how to approach any new project:

Experiment A — The Atom (pp. 34-35)

Choose one grain of rice, salt crystal, or raisin for a specific friend. This compresses the full methodology into a single act: empathy (selection reflects real knowledge of the friend), sensory attention (hold the item, mark the sensation), and aesthetic framing (place it deliberately in a drawn frame). The atom is the irreducible proof of concept.

Experiment B — The Frame (pp. 57-58)

Label the frame with the friend's name, turning it into a point of view. Add everyday objects; apply the keep/remove test (does this serve the frame's meaning?). This proves that context design is content design — change the frame and you change the experience without touching the content. "Inside the frame, objects are not objects; they are signifiers for your friend." (p. 57)

Experiment C — The Invitation (pp. 121-123)

Design an invitation that is the experience's first act, not a logistical precursor. Clarify intention, set structure (ask guests to bring or wear something specific), connect to a shared narrative. "The invitation is the beginning. It's a porous frame, and it extends in time from the moment the invitation is received until the end of the meal." (p. 123)

Experiment D — The Structure (pp. 183-185)

Map a meal as a temporal, multisensory composition. Plot psychological and physical immersion on split Y-axes across time. Design frame entry (greeting + threshold ritual) and frame exit (departure ritual). Determine which elements to control in detail and which to leave open: "Design some elements in minute detail, allow others to emerge from your interactions. Leave some things up to chance." (p. 183)

Experiment E — The Event

Execute the designed meal. The meal should have eventness — a focal moment that distinguishes it from pleasant background conditions. Without eventness, there is no peak, no memory anchor, and the experience becomes indistinguishable from routine.

Action sequence for practitioners: Atom -> Frame -> Invitation -> Structure -> Event. Each layer depends on the previous. Skip no steps.

Counterpoints: Common Execution Failures

1. Spectacle-chasing. Designers invest in the flashy centerpiece while neglecting logistical design. The Lightning Field's power comes not from lightning (most visitors never see it) but from what the logistical scaffolding does to attention — removing decisions, planning, and waiting so the only remaining role is to attend. (p. 7)

2. Single-channel design. Designing only the primary medium (food for a meal, visuals for an exhibit) produces a product, not an experience. Human perception is integrative. Every experience has a dominant channel, but design must happen across all channels simultaneously. (p. 183)

3. Over-scripting. Total control kills liveness. "The defining quality of liveness is the unknown." (p. 125) Scripted interactions with new people each time can feel dead; the same waltz danced 100 times can feel alive when openness remains.

4. Under-designing. The opposite error: leaving everything to emergence produces formlessness. The designer's real decision is which elements to control and which to leave open. Without deliberate structure, immersion is accidental.

5. Treating touchpoints as transitions. Interactions are the moments from which audiences assemble memories. Optimizing touchpoints for throughput produces efficient but forgettable experiences. "They should, therefore, be the most carefully considered design elements." (p. 75)

6. Empathy as projection. Casual identification ("I feel you") skips the hard work of crossing difference. Rigorous empathetic research demands immersive engagement with someone whose life differs from your own — "the same activities without the precedent endorphin rush." (p. 31)

7. Pacing monotony. "Too many field trips turn the pilgrimage into a commute, and too much time in the same room becomes detention." (p. 75) Variety and pacing are structural requirements, not aesthetic preferences.

Key Quotes

  • "Phase Zero asks not What kind of house are you hoping to build but What kind of life are you hoping to build?" (p. 13)
  • "Everything that led up to your being here primed you to seek beauty." (p. 7)
  • "For the experience designer, the steel rods and concrete are the tools, and modes of attention and ways of being are the materials." (p. 8)
  • "Humility is, therefore, the first necessary tool." (p. 9)
  • "Ideas are easier to understand when we try them than when we just read about them." (p. 34)
  • "Put it all together in just the right way, however, and transformation is possible." (p. 75)

Rules of Thumb

  1. Experience before form. If you have chosen a medium before defining the experiential aim, restart Phase Zero.
  2. Build from the atom up. The smallest unit of your design should already encode empathy, sensory attention, and framing. If the atom is hollow, the whole structure will be.
  3. Design the approach, not just the center. The journey to an experience is priming, not friction. Investment recalibrates perceptual readiness. (p. 7)
  4. Plan your immersion arc as a Phase Zero deliverable. Determine target depth (physical / psychological / ontological), temporal shape, key touchpoints, and audience paths before content planning begins.
  5. Control some, release some. For every element you script, identify one you will leave to emergence. Neither total control nor total openness produces lived experience.
  6. The invitation is Act One. If your invitation is purely logistical, you have abandoned the anticipatory window — the period when participants rehearse, project, and emotionally invest.
  7. Sequence your touchpoints for variety. Alternate interaction modes; each has distinct experiential affordances. Repetition of any single mode degrades immersion.

Related References