Library
Writing the Uncanny · 11 of 23
Writing the Uncanny
literature HIGH

Ghost Modes and Point of View

Writing the Uncanny Dan Coxon and Richard V. Hirst (eds.)

Key Principle

Ghost fiction makes distinct technical demands depending on which relationship the writer takes to the ghost. Jenn Ashworth identifies four modes — visible, invisible (trace), active agent, and ghost POV — each with non-negotiable craft requirements. Clarifying which mode governs each section of the work gives the writer control over what the story can and cannot do. Combining modes is possible; failing to identify which mode is operating in a given section produces incoherence rather than complexity.

Why This Matters

The visible ghost risks cliché immediately; the reader's recognition of the convention arrives before the writer has established anything else, and pre-emptive recognition blunts effect. The trace ghost turns unreliability into a mechanism — scientific explanation remains available, the story opens to psychological interpretation, and the reader becomes an active participant in determining what is real. The active agent ghost provides plot structure but risks over-materialising what should remain liminal. The ghost POV offers the deepest formal liberation: the ghost's non-physical nature provides a principled reason to break point-of-view conventions that would otherwise require special pleading.

The mode that tends to go underused is Mode 2. Charlotte Perkins Gilman's "The Yellow Wallpaper" functions as a ghost story without anyone believing there is literally a ghost — it operates entirely through trace, through the domestic arrangements becoming hostile, through the narrator's inference of presence from disturbance. W.H. Auden's miniature thesis for this mode: "the crack in the teacup opens / A lane to the land of the dead." The everyday reveals the inexplicable, and nothing needs to be named.

Good Examples

Mode 1 — Acknowledgement without obedience: Beetlejuice's Miss Argentina bears the evidence of her suicide on bandaged wrists and wears her beauty-queen sash — recognition is immediate. But the uncanny pivot is the deviation: eternal administration, the bored receptionist. The cliché is established and then abandoned. "Acknowledgement without obedience is a helpful formula." (Section 25: Seeing Things and Saying Things) Pure cliché produces no effect; pure novelty loses the reader's orientation.

Mode 4 — Ghost who does not know it is dead: Ashworth's "Heaven on Earth" — Terry understands he is dead, but not that in life he was both lucky and selfish, "which is more important." The metaphorical revelation outweighs the literal one. The shock in this structure "comes not from the death or the haunting, but from the sickly realisation that we too have been dead to the world all along and did not know it." (Section 25: Seeing Things and Saying Things)

Mode 4 — Ghost POV as formal experiment: Muriel Spark's "The Portobello Road" narrates with "insouciant confidence that should not belong to anything as insubstantial as a speaking ghost." Ali Smith's Hotel World has the ghost actively figure out its own rules mid-narrative. Both justify formally experimental moves — first-person omniscient, time-spanning narration, access to other characters' interiority — through the ghost's non-embodied nature. (Section 25: Seeing Things and Saying Things)

Counterpoints

Mode 1 without departure: A ghost that appears exactly as convention dictates — period dress, wounds of death, chains — and does nothing to depart from that convention produces no effect. The reader has already supplied the story before the writer's story begins.

Mode 3 without structural purpose: When a ghost carries a message or enacts unfinished business, two diagnostic questions must have clear answers: what causes the ghost to become visible or worthy of notice, and what changes because of the ghost or the information it brings? If neither question has a clear answer, the ghost has no narrative function and will feel inert, a plot mechanism pretending to be a presence.

Ghost as trauma — symbolic before concrete: Morrison's Beloved succeeds because Beloved is "utterly real" before she is symbolic — she arrives with no signs of travel, no lines in her palms, and is "entirely of this world." The framework fails when the symbolic level overwhelms the story's concrete sensory reality. The ghost must be encountered before it is decoded, or the story becomes schematic. (Section 25: Seeing Things and Saying Things)

Key Quotes

"'Acknowledgement without obedience' is a helpful formula." — Jenn Ashworth (Section 25: Seeing Things and Saying Things)

"The everyday reveals the inexplicable." — Jenn Ashworth (Section 25: Seeing Things and Saying Things)

"If we do throw out the rules then our job is to make new rules, and to teach the reader, through the action of the story, what they are." — Jenn Ashworth (Section 25: Seeing Things and Saying Things)

"The shock in this type of story comes not from the death or the haunting, but from the sickly realisation that we too have been dead to the world all along and did not know it." — Jenn Ashworth (Section 25: Seeing Things and Saying Things)

Rules of Thumb

  • Before drafting, identify which of the four modes governs each section. If a section is operating across modes without clarity, choose one and commit.
  • For the visible ghost: establish the conventional appearance first (acknowledgement), then find the one detail that departs from it (disobedience). That detail is the story's hinge.
  • For the trace ghost: never name the ghost directly. Express it through disturbance — objects misplaced, doors that will not stay closed, the domestic space beginning to feel purposeful in its resistance.
  • For the ghost POV: list the ghost's specific capacities and limitations before writing. What can it know? What is it barred from? Teach the reader these rules through the action of the story, not through exposition.
  • For the ghost-who-doesn't-know-it's-dead: the metaphorical revelation (what the character was "dead to" in life) should outweigh the literal one. The literal is the delivery mechanism; the metaphorical is the cargo.
  • "Trauma abhors a vacuum": when one manifestation is expelled, another arrives. Ghost as trauma works structurally only when the concrete encounter precedes the symbolic reading.

Related References