Library
Building Imaginary Worlds: The Theory and History of Subcreation · 5 of 11
Building Imaginary Worlds: The Theory and History of Subcreation
Fiction Writing HIGH

Narrative Threads, Braids, and Fabric

Building Imaginary Worlds: The Theory and History of Subcreation Mark J. P. Wolf
narrative-thread narrative-braid narrative-fabric internarrative-theory sequence-elements retcon crossover encounter-order

Key Principle

Wolf introduces a three-level model of narrative organization in imaginary worlds:

  • Thread: A single causal chain following one character, object, or place. The basic unit of storytelling.
  • Braid: Multiple threads interwoven. Four degrees of braiding: none, thematic (parallel comparison), diegetic (shared locations or characters), and causal (events in one thread affect others).
  • Fabric: The emergent totality incorporating extra-narrative data -- maps, glossaries, genealogies, allusions. Fabric is what makes a world feel larger than any story told within it.

"Narrative is by far the most common structure found in imaginary worlds, and the reason that most of them exist in the first place" (Chapter 4), but fabric is what enables worlds to transcend their source narratives and become independently explorable entities. Audiences construct emergent threads (e.g., Han Solo's compiled life story across films, novels, and specials) that no single author assembled.

Why This Matters

The thread-braid-fabric hierarchy explains how imaginary worlds achieve the appearance of autonomous existence. A world is initially designed to fit a narrative, but as the world grows, its logic begins to restrict and generate new narratives. Ruins on a map imply construction and destruction without any story telling it. Extra-narrative material becomes "the seeds of new, connected stories" (Chapter 4).

Wolf proposes internarrative theory to study how multiple separate stories set in the same world relate to one another -- distinct from intertextuality, which addresses relationships between texts more broadly. Imaginary worlds are transnarrative in scope, containing separate stories conceived independently, sometimes by different authors, that do not always require knowledge of each other (Chapter 4).

A critical structural reversal occurs with sequels: "While the world is originally designed to accommodate the first story set in it, the world is already in existence when the sequel is made, and the sequel's story must be made to fit the world" (Chapter 4). The world that once served the story now constrains it.

Good Examples

  • The six sequence elements classify how worlds expand along every temporal axis: sequel (after), prequel (before), interquel (between works), intraquel (within a gap inside one work), transquel (encompassing existing works in a larger framework), and paraquel (simultaneous). Prequels rely on dramatic irony: "A prequel, then, is not so much about the destination, but about the journey to that destination" (Chapter 4).
  • Interquels face a distinctive trade-off: "the more an interquel introduces new characters and new material, the more original and less determined by existing stories it becomes, yet it also becomes less connected to those stories at the same time" (Chapter 4). Lucas restricted Clone Wars-era novels before the prequel trilogy to preserve creative options.
  • Narrative resolution (adapted from Genette's "narrative speed") measures granularity of detail. Tolkien's backstory seeds were planted at low resolution in The Lord of the Rings, then expanded decades later. "The looseness provided by low narrative resolution lets a subcreator sketch out the history of a world without having to commit to a high level of detail, allowing it to be determined later and leaving more options open" (Chapter 4).
  • The unreliable narrator as consistency mechanism: When Tolkien revised The Hobbit's Riddle Game chapter, he attributed the discrepancy to Bilbo's own authorship -- Bilbo had lied about obtaining the Ring. "This departure from truth on the part of a most honest hobbit was a portent of great significance" (Chapter 4). The production error was transmuted into world lore.

Counterpoints

  • Retconning violates the implicit author-audience social contract but exposes a deeper truth: "it is the world, not any individual work set in it, that is the author's final product, reminding the audience that what they are witnessing are merely stages of development of a final form not yet attained" (Chapter 4). Every published work is provisional.
  • Encounter order reshapes meaning, not just experience. Release order preserves discovery; chronological order substitutes irony. Transmedia entry points multiply possible orderings, making the "same" world actually many different worlds depending on audience path. World- builders cannot fully determine what their world means because they cannot control encounter order (Chapter 4).
  • Crossovers and retroactive linkages can produce absurd ontological implications when accumulated carelessly. The Tommy Westphall Universe (282 linked TV shows) demonstrates how casual crossovers generate unintended commitments. "Retroactive linkages can alter the context and canonicity of a work, and change how an audience sees a particular world and the overarching narratives taking place within it; so it must be done carefully, if it is to be done at all" (Chapter 4).
  • Combining a world with interactivity is fundamentally different from combining a narrative with interactivity: "an interactive world does not require a predetermined narrative, and... the structure of a world is often more robust when it comes to user-led exploration" (Chapter 4).

Key Quotes

"Narrative is by far the most common structure found in imaginary worlds, and the reason that most of them exist in the first place." -- Mark J. P. Wolf, Chapter 4

"Retconning, then, reveals that it is the world, not any individual work set in it, that is the author's final product, reminding the audience that what they are witnessing are merely stages of development of a final form not yet attained." -- Mark J. P. Wolf, Chapter 4

"While the world is originally designed to accommodate the first story set in it, the world is already in existence when the sequel is made, and the sequel's story must be made to fit the world." -- Mark J. P. Wolf, Chapter 4

"the more an interquel introduces new characters and new material, the more original and less determined by existing stories it becomes, yet it also becomes less connected to those stories at the same time." -- Mark J. P. Wolf, Chapter 4

Rules of Thumb

  • Use low narrative resolution for backstory and world history to preserve flexibility for later expansion into full narratives.
  • The inverse freedom-connectivity law governs franchise expansion: as constraints from existing works tighten, ties to the world itself (rather than narrative links) grow in importance as connective tissue.
  • When a world outgrows its original narrative, the world constrains the story rather than the other way around. Successful sequels restore novelty by revealing new areas of the world.
  • The unreliable narrator is a practical retroactive-revision mechanism: attribute information to in-world characters rather than omniscient narration to retain the option of declaring that source unreliable.
  • Design for multiple encounter orders. The world should cohere regardless of whether audiences enter through the first work, a sequel, or a transmedial extension.
  • Exploit interlace rather than organic unity for world-heavy fiction: interlace "seeks to mirror the perception of the flux of events in the world around us, where everything is happening at once" (Chapter 3).

Related References