Library
The Writing of Fiction · 11 of 12
The Writing of Fiction
writing CRITICAL

The Illuminating Incident

The Writing of Fiction Edith Wharton
illuminating-incident anticipatory-flash significance selection

Key Principle

The novelist's chief instrument is the illuminating incident: the episode that "reveal[s] and emphasize[s] the inner meaning of each situation" — "the magic casements of fiction, its vistas on infinity." Each one "shed[s] a circle of light far beyond the incident recorded."

These incidents are "the most personal element in any narrative, the author's most direct contribution; nothing gives such immediate proof of the quality of his imagination as his choice of such episodes." Choosing them is selection at its most concentrated and least imitable.

Why This Matters

The mechanism is efficiency of meaning: "the more threads of significance are gathered up into each one, the more pages of explanatory narrative are spared." A single rightly chosen incident does the work of a chapter of analysis — and does it by showing rather than explaining. This is why the choice reveals the writer's imagination so nakedly: no technique can be borrowed to make it, because the incident must be drawn from the writer's own vision of what the situation means.

But the incident is not the whole of the art. "The choice of the illuminating incident ... is not all. There is the manner. As every tale contains its own dimension, so it implies its own manner."

Good Examples

  • Lucien writing drinking-songs as his mistress lies dying — the incident exposes his whole nature in a stroke.
  • Henry Esmond watching Beatrix descend the stairs in scarlet stockings.
  • Stendhal's Julien taking Mme. de Rênal's hand — "in half a page, more than a whole chapter of analysis."
  • Proust's "Combray" goodnight-kiss (the anticipatory flash at its peak): the boy's anguish at his mother's withheld kiss is linked to Swann's lifelong anguish, illuminating "the central theme of the book: the hopeless incurable passion of a sensitive man for a stupid uncomprehending woman."
  • The end as a closing incident. "No conclusion can be right which is not latent in the first page"; the final illuminating incident "should send a long enough shaft to meet the light cast forward from the first page."

Counterpoints

  • The trivial incident over-weighted. Over-correcting away from arbitrary plot, writers fail by "giving an exaggerated importance to trivial incidents." The cure: an incident "insignificant in itself, must illustrate some general law, and turn on some deep movement of the soul" — "If the novelist wants to hang his drama on a button, let it at least be one of Lear's."
  • Mere situation without rendering. "There is nothing in mere 'situation' — the whole of the novelist's art lies in the particular way in which he brings the given conjuncture home to the imagination." The situation is inert; only the rendering illuminates.

Key Quotes

"Illuminating incidents are the magic casements of fiction, its vistas on infinity." — Edith Wharton, Chapter III: Constructing a Novel

"No conclusion can be right which is not latent in the first page." — Edith Wharton, Chapter III: Constructing a Novel

"If the novelist wants to hang his drama on a button, let it at least be one of Lear's." — Edith Wharton, Chapter IV: Character and Situation in the Novel

Rules of Thumb

  • Seek the incident that radiates — one that gathers many threads of meaning and spares pages of explanation.
  • Prefer showing a deep movement of the soul to explaining it; the right small incident outperforms a chapter of analysis.
  • Make the closing incident answer the opening — the end should meet the light cast forward from the first page.
  • A trivial incident earns its place only if it turns on a general law of the human heart.

Related References