Library
Win Without Pitching · 6 of 12
Win Without Pitching
Entrepreneurship HIGH

Implementation Playbook

Win Without Pitching Blair Enns
implementation action-plan sequence pitfalls

Key Principle

The twelve proclamations form a sequential dependency chain -- each becomes achievable only when the preceding ones are practiced. Implementation must start with specialization (Ch. 1) because every subsequent proclamation depends on the positioning power it creates. Attempting to implement later proclamations without the foundational ones produces contradictions: a generalist firm that tries to "charge more" (Ch. 11) without specializing first will simply lose clients rather than filter them.

The dependency chain runs in four phases, from positioning foundation through pricing power. Partial adoption produces partial results at best and active harm at worst. The firm's ability to control an engagement diminishes with time -- it never recovers -- so each phase must be built on solid ground before advancing.

Why This Matters

Creative professionals resist systematic implementation because of the same novelty-seeking psychology that makes them good at craft. The temptation is to cherry-pick the most appealing proclamations (often the money ones) and skip the difficult foundational work. But without specialization, the firm has no basis for the practitioner role. Without a diagnostic process, it has no structural reason to refuse client-dictated processes. Without selectivity, it cannot walk away from poor fits. Each skip creates a gap that undermines everything built on top of it.

The correct response to financial anxiety is to deepen expertise, not to widen the funnel. Firms under revenue pressure are most tempted to abandon the sequence -- accepting any client, cutting prices, pitching for free. This is precisely when adherence matters most, because backsliding accelerates the drift toward commodity status.

Good Examples

Phase 1 -- Foundation (Chapters 1-3):

  • Make The Difficult Business Decision: choose a specialization focus. This is the bottleneck -- steps that follow are "easy" once this is done. (Ch. 1)
  • Break the presentation addiction: replace performer dynamics with practitioner dynamics. The role set in the buying cycle carries through the entire engagement. "Stars do not audition." (Ch. 2)
  • Build a diagnostic process: formalize methodology so the firm has a structural basis to resist client-imposed processes. The process void will be filled by whoever has a process -- make sure it is the firm's. (Ch. 3)

Phase 2 -- Sales Transformation (Chapters 4-6):

  • Reframe selling as change management: match approach to the client's stage of readiness. Help the unaware, inspire the interested, reassure the intent. (Ch. 4)
  • Eliminate written proposals: "We propose to do X for you, over Y timeframe, for Z price." All substance in conversation; paper only after agreement. (Ch. 5)
  • Practice selectivity: pursue no early, raise objections before the client does, test with the retreat-and-follow dynamic. (Ch. 6)

Phase 3 -- Expertise Building (Chapter 7):

  • Write: "Writing forces exploration of the deep crevices of a territory." (Ch. 7) It bridges internal expertise and external credibility.
  • Formalize processes: documented processes reassure late-stage buyers -- "little variability in process equals little variability in outcomes." (Ch. 7)
  • Train and empower: distribute expertise across the organization. Not everyone will follow; some must be let go.

Phase 4 -- Pricing Power (Chapters 8-11):

  • Get paid before working: establish deposits as policy. "We'll get started as soon as we receive the deposit, as is our policy for all new clients." (Ch. 8)
  • Talk money early: use the MLE (Minimum Level of Engagement) in every first conversation. (Ch. 9)
  • Refuse losses: every for-profit engagement must be profitable from day one. Margin never recovers. (Ch. 10)
  • Charge more: price strategic work in big round numbers; absorb tactical changes in healthy margins. (Ch. 11)

Counterpoints

The sequential model can become a rationalization for inaction -- "We can't work on pricing until our positioning is perfect." In practice, phases overlap and firms must make progress on multiple fronts simultaneously. The sequence describes priority, not a strict waterfall. A firm can begin talking money earlier (Ch. 9) while still refining its specialization, provided it recognizes that the money conversations will become easier as positioning strengthens.

The framework also assumes the firm's principals have the authority and will to make these changes. In firms with multiple partners or institutional inertia, the bottleneck may be internal politics rather than market positioning. "Most people will change their desires, even their values, before they will change their behavior." (Ch. 7)

Key Quotes

  1. "There is no enemy. We are victims only of a creative mind that makes choosing a focus more difficult for us than most." (Ch. 1)

  2. "If design truly is a process, then we will define and guard that process and we will walk away from those clients and situations, like the pitch, where the process is dictated to us." (Ch. 3)

  3. "It is irresponsible of us to use our identity as artists as an excuse for not forming business standards and policies." (Ch. 8)

  4. "The skills we must possess or acquire in order to succeed in a differentiated creative enterprise are: consulting first, writing second, artistry third." (Ch. 7)

  5. "Free pitching and speculative creative will only be beaten one firm at a time." (Introduction)

Rules of Thumb

  • Start with specialization. Everything else follows from the positioning power it creates. Skipping it makes every subsequent step harder or impossible.
  • The process void will be filled by whoever has a process. If the firm does not formalize its diagnostic methodology, the client fills the void with his own.
  • Never mistake interest for intent. The unaware need education, not meetings. The interested need inspiration, not proposals. The intent need reassurance, not inspiration.
  • The correct response to financial anxiety is to deepen expertise, not widen the funnel. Backsliding under revenue pressure accelerates commodity drift.
  • Frame standards as policy, not preference. "It is our policy" commands respect; "We prefer" invites negotiation.
  • Each phase builds confidence for the next. The money proclamations (Ch. 8-11) form their own internal cascade that depends on the positioning foundation (Ch. 1-3).

Related References