Library
Convergence Culture: Where Old and New Media Collide · 4 of 11
Convergence Culture: Where Old and New Media Collide
ARG Design CRITICAL

Convergence Culture Core Framework

Convergence Culture: Where Old and New Media Collide Henry Jenkins
convergence participatory-culture collective-intelligence black-box-fallacy media-theory

Problem This Solves

Most people misunderstand media convergence as a technological process -- the idea that all media functions will eventually merge into a single device or platform. This leads to what Jenkins calls the "Black Box Fallacy" and produces misguided strategies built on replacement logic (new media killing old media). It also obscures the cultural behaviors actually driving change.

Jenkins provides a corrective framework showing that convergence is fundamentally a cultural shift occurring within people's brains and social interactions, not inside devices. His three-pillar model (media convergence, participatory culture, collective intelligence) explains how content flows across platforms, how consumers have become active participants rather than passive audiences, and how communities pool distributed knowledge to create collective power.

Key Principle

Convergence is a cultural process, not a technological endpoint. It operates simultaneously as a top-down corporate-driven process and a bottom-up consumer-driven process, with the tension between these forces reshaping popular culture. Old media never die -- delivery technologies become obsolete, but media as cultural systems persist and evolve. As Ithiel de Sola Pool first articulated in 1983, convergence does not mean ultimate stability or unity -- it operates as a constant force for unification but always in dynamic tension with change. Two forces broke down the walls between media: digitization set the conditions for convergence; corporate conglomerates created its imperative.

Good Examples

  • The "Bert is Evil" meme: A Filipino-American high school student's Photoshop collage traveled from bedroom to World Wide Web to Bangladeshi print shop to anti-American protest posters to CNN coverage -- demonstrating how content circulates unpredictably across both corporate and grassroots channels.

  • Hardware divergence, content convergence: Cheskin Research (2002) documented that while people carry increasingly specialized devices (laptops, cell phones, iPods, Game Boys), the same content flows across all of them. Context-dependent media use drives device specialization, not consolidation.

  • The Yellow Arrows project: People affixed stickers with phone numbers on public spaces to share voice annotations of the urban landscape -- grassroots convergence. Companies then co-opted the system for advertising -- corporate convergence. Both forces operating on the same phenomenon.

Bad Examples

  • The Black Box Fallacy: The mistaken belief that "all media content is going to flow through a single black box into our living rooms." Sony and Microsoft debated at the New Orleans Media Experience about how to expand game consoles into all-purpose media hubs, but "hadn't figured out why anyone would want it." The fallacy "reduces media change to technological change and strips aside the cultural levels."

  • The Digital Revolution Paradigm: Nicholas Negroponte's prediction that broadcast networks would collapse in favor of narrowcasting, and George Gilder's comparison of computers replacing TV to automobiles replacing horses. This replacement logic was discredited by the dot-com crash -- new media did not destroy old media.

  • Assuming corporate consolidation equals convergence: "Political economists and business gurus make convergence sound so easy; they look at the charts that show the concentration of media ownership as if they ensure that all of the parts will work together to pursue maximum profits. But from the ground, many of the big media giants look like great big dysfunctional families."

Key Quotes

"By convergence, I mean the flow of content across multiple media platforms, the cooperation between multiple media industries, and the migratory behavior of media audiences who will go almost anywhere in search of the kinds of entertainment experiences they want." -- Jenkins, Introduction

"Convergence does not occur through media appliances, however sophisticated they may become. Convergence occurs within the brains of individual consumers and through their social interactions with others." -- Jenkins, Introduction

"Delivery systems are simply and only technologies; media are also cultural systems. Delivery technologies come and go all the time, but media persist as layers within an ever more complicated information and entertainment stratum." -- Jenkins, Introduction

"Convergence, as we can see, is both a top-down corporate-driven process and a bottom-up consumer-driven process. Corporate convergence coexists with grassroots convergence." -- Jenkins, Introduction

Rules of Thumb

  • Convergence takes place within the same appliance, within the same franchise, within the same company, within the brain of the consumer, and within the same fandom -- examine all five sites.
  • When analyzing any media phenomenon, examine the cultural behaviors driving content across platforms rather than defaulting to technology-centered explanations.
  • Distinguish between media (which persist and evolve) and delivery technologies (which become obsolete) -- recorded sound is the medium; CDs, MP3 files, and 8-track cassettes are delivery technologies.
  • Track how content circulates across both corporate and grassroots channels -- convergence depends on both directions.
  • Expect device proliferation rather than consolidation; design for content that flows across multiple situated contexts.
  • Recognize that consumers are active participants, not passive audiences, but acknowledge that participation is unequal -- power asymmetries between corporations and individuals persist.
  • Convergence refers to a process, not an endpoint: "Ready or not, we are already living within a convergence culture."
  • Shift concern from the "digital divide" (access to technology) to the "participation gap" (ability to participate in convergence culture) -- reform should focus on cultural protocols and practices, not just technology access.
  • Printed words did not kill spoken words. Cinema did not kill theater. Television did not kill radio. Old media are not displaced -- their functions and status shift with new technologies.

Related References